which one should i melt?

hi there!, i got those 2 guys:


their stats at lvl46 to compare

1st one:
2 slots
301 critical hit rate
15,8% critical dmg

2nd one:
4 slots
297 critical hit rate
9,7% critical hit dmg

and i have no feeling about wich one to keep cause it is:
2 slots (that means two 6,5% sapphires) + 15 dmg Vs 6,1% critical dmg + higher critical hit rate increases lvling

pleaaaase heeeeelp!!

 

I would definitely melt the 1st and keep the 2nd.....

 

Try both of them in this: http://dsopage.bplaced.net/
Keep the one with the higher DPI - problem solved.

But i wouldn´t keep any of them, they could both be a lot better IMO.

GL!

 

Why so much hesitate? They both suck.
Leave the second one until you find better.

 

i know Trakilaki.. but if i only open garbage.. what i can do?... i have to select the more playable things

 

Try to make your comparisons as equal as possible, before deciding.
Remove the gems. The base price is what DSO considers the more valuable (useful) and is probably the better item for the short run.

The calculations for critical damage make overall damage effectiveness hard to calculate. The damage performance index or the DSO_calculating_character_strength2 programs can may it easier, especially if offense and defense both vary.

The gem slots make a difference too. If you will never have enough andermant to add slots, the one with 2 less gem slots is at a distinct disadvantage.

Both items will probably be temporary for you. Which one matches your style the most?